Unearthing Hidden Gems: 14 Underrated NFL Free Agents Poised to Shine in 2025

The 2025 NFL free agent class may not boast the most glamorous names, but for astute teams, there’s significant value to be found in the secondary and third tiers of players. Here’s a deep dive into 14 players who could emerge as steals in the upcoming free agency period.

Carlton Davis III, CB, Detroit Lions

Age entering 2025 season: 28 Davis, recovering from a broken jaw, was a standout CB1 in Detroit’s man-heavy defense. Despite his injury history, his versatility and press-man skills make him a valuable asset. Teams like the Ravens and Colts could benefit from his experience and coverage abilities.

Will Fries, G, Indianapolis Colts

Age entering 2025 season: 27 Fries, a surprising standout from Penn State, has solidified himself as one of the best young guards in the league. His technical proficiency and power make him a reliable option in pass protection. Teams like the Chargers and Patriots could vie for his services.

Rico Dowdle, RB, Dallas Cowboys

Age entering 2025 season: 27 Dowdle found his rhythm late in the 2024 season, showcasing his ability as a grind-it-out back. While not explosive, his success rate and late-season performance make him a viable option for teams seeking a committee back.

Jamien Sherwood, LB, New York Jets

Age entering 2025 season: 25 Sherwood’s range and tackling prowess make him a high-impact linebacker. His potential as a three-down linebacker could be maximized in a blitz-heavy defense. Teams like the Steelers and Rams could see him as a key addition.

Justin Reid, S, Kansas City Chiefs

Age entering 2025 season: 28 Reid, a prototypical split-field safety, brings leadership and reliability to any defense. His experience and ability to step down and tackle from depth make him a valuable asset for teams like the Jaguars and Panthers.

Paulson Adebo, CB, New Orleans Saints

Age entering 2025 season: 26 Adebo’s pass-defense numbers are impressive, but his recent femur injury adds risk. However, his ability to handle high-target rates makes him a potential steal for teams with open CB2 spots, like the Patriots and Chiefs.

Malcolm Koonce, Edge, Las Vegas Raiders

Age entering 2025 season: 27 Koonce’s 2023 film showcased his potential as a disruptive edge rusher. Teams with deep rotations, like the Ravens and Chiefs, could benefit from his high-effort play and pass-rushing skills.

Deep Cuts

• Jack Sanborn, LB, Chicago Bears: A hard-nosed linebacker who excels in base defense.
• Isaiah Rodgers, CB, Philadelphia Eagles: A rangy corner with man-coverage traits.
• Noah Igbinoghene, CB, Washington Commanders: A former first-round pick finding his niche in the slot.
• Ben Bredeson, G, Tampa Bay Buccaneers: A solid, versatile guard.
• K’Lavon Chaisson, Edge, Las Vegas Raiders: A designated pass rusher showing signs of improvement.
• Poona Ford, DT, Los Angeles Chargers: A versatile defensive tackle.
• Juwan Johnson, TE, New Orleans Saints: A mismatch problem in play-action-heavy offenses.

These players may not headline the free agency period, but their potential to outperform their contracts makes them invaluable additions for teams looking to build a competitive roster.